What is ruled when a replacement relief pitcher attempts a pick-off with an exceeded pitched innings count?

When a replacement relief pitcher attempts a pick-off after exceeding the pitched innings count, the correct ruling is that his attempt is counted as a pitch. This is because any action taken by the pitcher while on the mound, including a pick-off attempt, constitutes a pitch, regardless of the count or status of the pitcher in terms of innings pitched.

In baseball, each pick-off attempt is considered an active participation in the game, essentially similar to throwing a pitch to the batter. Therefore, even if the pitcher is no longer eligible because he has exceeded his pitching limits, his actions still contribute to the overall count of pitches thrown during that game. Recognizing this helps umpires and players understand the rules surrounding pitching limits and their enforcement during play.

Options that suggest a defense can replace the pitcher immediately or result in a game forfeit are incorrect as the action of attempting a pick-off does not directly lead to those outcomes. Additionally, the idea that only an umpire can override the decision does not apply in this case, as the situation is clearly defined by the rules regarding pitching limits and pitch counts.