What happens if F1 makes a legal feint to F4 while R2 is on second base?

When a legal feint is made by the pitcher (F1) toward a base, such as to F4, while a runner (R2) is on second base, it's important to recognize the distinction between what constitutes a legal action and what might be viewed as an infraction. In this scenario, a legal feint is considered a normal and acceptable part of the pitcher's strategy to keep the runner at second base from advancing or to create an opportunity for a pick-off.

The rule allows the pitcher to engage in feinting movements as long as they are not deceptive or misleading in a way that violates any specific rules. Since the feint is executed legally—meaning it complies with the rules of the game—there are no penalties assessed for this action. Therefore, the appropriate outcome of the situation is that no penalty occurs.

Understanding this context highlights how legal actions by players are integral to gameplay strategy in baseball and underscores the importance of distinguishing between acceptable tactics and violations of the rules.